Skip to content
VECTOR WIREAI INTELLIGENCE
UTC
Home

California fines robotaxi operators that block first responders under SB 1246

Up to $10,000 per-vehicle fine for blocking emergency responders more than 30 minutes after a technician is requested.

Courts can order fines of up to $10,000 per vehicle when a commercial autonomous vehicle obstructs or interferes with an emergency for more than 30 minutes, under SB 1246, the California robotaxi law Governor Gavin Newsom signed on September 304. A separate penalty of up to $5,000 applies to each violation of the law's dispatch rules. City attorneys or county counsel must bring the cases; violations are civil, not criminal.

The 30-minute clock starts from the moment an emergency response official requests a local incident technician. The court weighs how long the blockage lasted, whether it was repeated, and whether causes beyond the company's reasonable control contributed.

The law takes effect July 1, 20283.

What the law requires

SB 1246 mandates that AV developers including Tesla, Waymo, and Zoox notify cities and other local jurisdictions about the location and status of vehicles during system-wide failures1. Companies must dispatch a local incident technician immediately after a crash or a responder's request, and those technicians must be able to relocate or tow the vehicle. Companies must keep an emergency phone line that a human answers within 30 seconds and must act on a responder's geofencing message within two minutes.

Remote drivers who directly control a vehicle from a distance must be located in the United States and hold a license valid in California. Remote staff must also be able to put driverless commercial vehicles without manual controls in neutral or switch them off. Tesla is the only company that has publicly reported having operators capable of taking direct control of its robotaxis. Waymo and other companies have said they use remote assistance in which the driverless system continues to operate the controls while an employee provides guidance.

Companies must report response times to the California Department of Motor Vehicles every quarter, and the DMV will publish summary statistics for each company. The DMV must set response-time guidelines by July 1, 2028.

The incidents behind the law

The legislation follows a series of incidents in California in which robotaxis broke down and disrupted traffic, drove into crime scenes, or impeded first responders. The bulk of those incidents involved Waymo, the largest robotaxi operator in the U.S., which has about 4,000 autonomous vehicles in its commercial fleet across the country, with roughly 1,200 in the San Francisco Bay Area. More than 500,000 Waymo rides are completed every week5.

Senator Dave Cortese, who introduced the bill, cited a December power outage in San Francisco that stalled around 1,500 Waymo vehicles and an incident during this year's Fourth of July celebrations in which multiple Waymo vehicles blocked streets after running out of power6,8. A TechCrunch investigation found emergency responders were regularly asked to operate Waymo vehicles during day-to-day operations and crisis scenarios, including removing obstructing vehicles from escape paths during a wildfire. Cortese's office said first responders trying to reach the companies waited on hold for up to 53 minutes.

"California has embraced autonomous vehicles, but we cannot embrace innovation at the expense of public safety," Cortese said in a press release.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration said in July it had identified "a clear pattern" of driverless vehicles interfering with law enforcement and other first responders. The Assembly passed SB 1246 by 65 to 11 on August 30, and the Senate agreed to the final version 29 to 7 the next day.

A Waymo spokesperson said the company is committed to making roads safer in California and is "grateful for the amendments made to the bill," adding that the amendments "ensure autonomous vehicle operators can still feasibly serve Californians". Waymo and Zoox said they would comply with the new rules7.

ANALYSIS The fine structure, quarterly DMV reporting, and 30-second phone-answer mandate collectively shift a portion of emergency-response burden from municipal first responders back to the companies whose vehicles create the obstruction. The requirement for U.S.-based, California-licensed remote drivers adds a labor-localization constraint that could affect how AV companies staff their remote operations as fleets scale.

Was this useful?

The day’s vector, in your inbox.

Vector Wire Daily: one dispatch each publishing day.