The two federal positions most responsible for defending the United States against cyberattacks are now simultaneously vacant or contested, and the administration's own timeline for filling them runs through a Senate that is about to change hands.
White House National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross is out3,11. The same day, the president's nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, Palantir chief information security officer Michael LoSapio, drew bipartisan holds on his confirmation after denying that the Capitol was attacked on January 6, 20218. The result is that neither of the federal government's two principal cyber-defense posts has a confirmed, functioning leader, at a moment when a string of outages has already tested public confidence in digital infrastructure.
Cairncross' departure was described as amicable by two sources, according to Axios. A senior administration official told Axios that the new White House chief of staff, Stephen Miller, sought the change. Fox News, citing its own sources, reported that Trump backed Cairncross' firing over concerns he lacked the cybersecurity credentials for the job14. Reuters separately reported that Cairncross was fired and that the president fully supported the decision1. The White House named Kirsten A. Davies, the Pentagon's chief information officer, as the new national cyber director. Davies will serve in an acting capacity.
The timing is driven by the Senate calendar. Cairncross is leaving now to give the White House enough time to get a successor confirmed before Democrats take control of the Senate in January, according to Axios2,13. The national cyber director position requires Senate confirmation. That gives the administration roughly six weeks to move a nominee through a Republican Senate.
Davies brings more technical depth than her predecessor. Axios noted she has more experience in the field than Cairncross, an attorney who took office in August 2025. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton praised her background, writing on social media that she brings "nearly two decades of leadership experience in the technology space". Secretary of State Marco Rubio also publicly welcomed the appointment. The speed of those endorsements from senior national-security officials suggests the administration wants to frame Davies' arrival as an upgrade rather than a crisis response, but the underlying fact remains: the Office of the National Cyber Director is in transition during a period of active infrastructure disruption.
That disruption is the backdrop for both personnel moves. Cairncross' departure comes as the country reels from a series of technological outages that hit Microsoft services, air traffic control systems, banks, and the National Security Agency's internal network. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told lawmakers he is "98% confident" the outages are not the result of malicious foreign activity, though he acknowledged he had "absolutely not" seen so many outages in a short period. DNI Clayton stated on November 18: "This is not a cyber attack and this is not a coordinated effort by a nation-state". Vector Wire reported on November 1 that AI-agent-driven cyberattacks had moved from theoretical risk to operational reality, with autonomous hacking campaigns breaching more than 100 companies in a single spree[4]. Whether or not the recent outages prove to be adversarial, the scale of disruption makes the leadership vacuum harder to dismiss as procedural.
The CISA side of the equation is, if anything, more troubled. LoSapio's confirmation hearing before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee lasted less than an hour7. He offered only high-level answers about how he would restore CISA's ability to combat cyber threats after two years of Trump administration cuts10. When asked about cybersecurity resilience in the wake of the outages, LoSapio said organizations should be more proactive implementing baseline protections around inventory, evaluation, and patching internet-connected devices. He described CISA as "the cybersecurity version of the 911 system". CISA has gone nearly two years without a Senate-confirmed director6.
But the hearing pivoted sharply to January 6. Sen. Richard Blumenthal asked LoSapio whether the Capitol had been attacked that day. LoSapio first said he did not know how to classify the events, then stated: "No, I don't believe it was an attack, no"5. Pressed again, he repeated the answer. He also declined to name the popular-vote winner of the 2020 election, saying he would not answer a question about an election six years earlier. Blumenthal responded: "Were you alive on the planet?"12.
The political fallout was immediate and bipartisan. Sen. Ron Wyden, a Democrat, told Nextgov/FCW: "You can't have an insurrectionist Palantir executive in charge of our nation's cybersecurity and election security. I will place a hold on Mr. LoSapio's nomination". Sen. Thom Tillis, a Republican, separately said he plans to place a hold as well. A hold signals that a senator will object to moving a nomination quickly by unanimous consent; Senate leaders can still pursue confirmation if they have sufficient support, but doing so consumes time on an already crowded calendar. If LoSapio's nomination remains pending when this Congress ends, Trump would have to nominate him again for consideration in the next one.
ANALYSIS The Tillis hold is the more consequential development. Republican opposition removes the possibility that the majority can simply muscle the nomination through on a party-line vote during the lame-duck session. LoSapio's Jan. 6 remarks gave a GOP senator political cover to block a nominee whose cybersecurity credentials were already under scrutiny, and the calendar does the rest.
Palantir's presence in both stories is worth noting. LoSapio is Palantir's chief information security officer. The company also added Tom Watson as a senior vice president in October. Cairncross, for his part, held technical meetings with Anthropic leaders over the summer after Commerce Department export controls effectively scrubbed the company's models from the internet. The revolving door between defense-tech firms and federal cyber posts is not new, but the simultaneous vacancy of both top positions while a defense-tech executive's confirmation stalls creates an unusual gap in the chain of command.
Vector Wire reported in September that the administration's plan for an "AI Force" was designed to protect industry growth[2]. The White House's voluntary AI accord, signed in late October, relied on self-policing as Congress stalled on legislation[5]. Cyber defense is the domain where that self-policing model faces its hardest test: the outages that preceded Cairncross' departure and dominated LoSapio's hearing are exactly the kind of infrastructure-level failures that voluntary frameworks cannot address.
Davies' confirmation timeline is the first marker. The White House has roughly six weeks to move her through the Republican Senate before Democrats take control in January. Whether LoSapio can survive the bipartisan holds and reach a floor vote in that same window will determine if CISA enters 2027 with a confirmed director for the first time in nearly two years. The administration has not disclosed whether it has a backup nominee if LoSapio's path closes.